We Need to Talk About Safety Tools

Yeah, yeah, I get it. Everyone agrees with them, there’s a bunch of videos about them, all conventions do them. Except – we don’t really. We don’t need them for trusted players, do we? We don’t need them in our home groups, only for conventions. We don’t need them if we’re just playing D&D, only for horror games. Well – these are all wrong. Let me tell you why we need to talk about them.

While you’re reading this, I should tell you about my Patreon. Patrons get access to content 7 days before they hit this site, and the chance to request articles or content, for a very reasonable backer level of £2 per month. If you like what you read, want to support the blog, and have the funds for it, please consider supporting here. Telling people about the blog, and sharing links/retweeting is much appreciated also – thanks!

Recently, I went to one of my favourite conventions. It has, if you check the website, a rigorous approach to safety tools. GMs offer games with “tags” that explicitly call out “conflicting agendas,” “PvP,” or similar – they can offer other tags as well, but those are mandatory if they feature in the game. All games are expected to have lines & veils, open table, and an X card in play, unless a discussion has happened with the organising committee. The huge, huge majority of people attending are those I’d gladly share a table with. And yet, I had a poor experience as a player in a couple of games there.

I just did not realise how much I absolutely despise mind control in games. I had no idea, probably because I’ve never encountered it before. But in two of the three games I played in, this featured. In one, a player rolled a social skill check to tell the rest of the group to leave another PC behind. In another, a player’s PC was mind controlled to attack the rest of the group – and successfully killed most of them – in the finale.

Neither game had an X card on the table, nor was one introduced, nor were lines & veils covered by the GM at the start. They were in a column on a spreadsheet, but they weren’t mentioned during the game. In the first game, I questioned it when it happened, and was dismissed (I did give proper feedback after the game, and in fairness I don’t think the GM realised how upset I was about it) – in the second game, I didn’t even bother. Both left quite a bad taste in the mouth.

But, but – I hear you say – you complain there weren’t safety tools, and yet you didn’t raise them yourself! Why didn’t you speak up? Well, while I’ll sometimes do this at the start of sessions at conventions – and I’m much more inclined to do so now – let me tell you, it is incredibly difficult to speak up if you are actually upset in a game. You project your state of mind on the game, and anticipate that the GM and other players will be similarly upset. It’s harder, in fact, if these are people you know well. There is a huge amount of social pressure to just put up. When I did raise it, and it was dismissed, that just reinforced this. And believe me, those of you that have met me, I am not normally someone who finds it hard to speak up in TTRPG circles.

That “tag” system? Neither game was tagged PvP. In fact the first game was tagged “No PvP” – and two of the PCs had secret missions the rest of us weren’t meant to know about!

What a shambles, you’re thinking. But – wait – I don’t really blame anyone for this, really. Two GMs had the best of intentions and made decisions that made the game exciting and interesting for other players. It just wasn’t for me. Should they have introduced safety tools? Well yes, but lots of con GMs don’t. Should the organisers have made a bigger deal of safety tools, and mentioned them in the “welcome speech?” Well, yes, but lots of con organisers don’t. Lots of conventions, and convention games, pay lip service to safety tools without really committing to them. And so I can’t really blame anyone for my experiences. I’ll go to that con again, I’ll play with those GMs again… but, we can do better.

We don’t need to pay lip service to safety tools. We can (and should) introduce them at the start of each session. We can refuse to undermine them with “well I know everyone at the table,” or “I’m running D&D, nothing upsetting will come up,” and use them anyway. We can use an X card if we’re not sure about it until we find something better, rather than dismissing it for spurious edge cases. We can insist on safety tools when we organise gaming events, and be unapologetic about our expectations about them. We can, in fact, insist on safety tools if we join a table as a player – and I will in future. It will make it better for everyone.

Because at the moment, lots of us are just half-assing them, and that’s not good enough. We need to actually talk about them.

6 Comments

  1. Unknown's avatar

    “Everyone agrees with them”
    “What a shambles, you’re thinking.”
    “But, but – I hear you say”
    Man, for someone who claims to hate mind control you sure do love to dictate what my thoughts are.

    Like

    Reply

    1. Unknown's avatar

      Worse than that!
      “…I hear you say …”
      Guy has actually taken over your voice box and is manipulating every word you utter!! What a villain!
      Or perhaps he’s using well regarding narrative constructions for effect. Maybe. Perhaps.

      Like

      Reply

      1. Unknown's avatar

        The obvious point being made is that said narrative constructions are used poorly. They’re intrusive, manipulative, and presumptive. Stop being obtuse.

        Like

  2. Unknown's avatar

    Also worth remembering that even if the GM thinks nothing bad will come up in a game there are a bunch of other people at the table who can introduce their own material through play.

    Like

    Reply

  3. Unknown's avatar

    X cards can be a useful tool. Some people are not good with reading or giving subtle hints, so it can be a good thing to have a “I am not having fun with this” signal available as it is still softer tool than starting an OOC complaint that can spiral to a derailing discussion, especially in a game with limited timeslot.

    Lines and veils can be an incredibly useful tool. What the game is about, what is not about? It’s much better to align on that before the campaign starts, and keep on aligning on regular basis.

    I just wish it wasn’t called “safety tool”. In the context of nearly all ttrpg gaming, that sounds ridiculous. Most of the time, I am sitting on a sofa, sharing the room with 3 to 5 other peaceable people, and we will mostly talk for 4 hours, and nobody will stop me leaving. Traveling to the convention is probably more unsafe than anything in the convention, because of risk of traffic accidents, which is among the baseline noise regular life. On the other side of the road, I doubt any X card will be much of use were someone (for whatever statistically extremely unlikely reason) to commit a genuine crime. When playing online, it is even more safe: I am sitting comfortably at home, and free to disconnect. I have difficulties imaging when my “safety” would be threatened. Perhaps in a game where someone tries to play mind games, it is no longer certain what is game narrative, or physically extreme forms of live action.

    Characters having unexpected PvP can be unfun. Player characters getting mind controlled can be unfun if you are not ready to roll with as a fiction. Avoiding unfun things is important. However, I would not call that safety management, I would call it is expectations management.

    It might be counterintuitive, but calling things by better names would genuinely help. I think more people might be more inclined to really use them instead of performatively using them. Very few GMs think anything truly unsafe will happen in their adventure. More GMs would be more willing to admit that stuff that is not so fun occasionally can happen, and these tools can help with that.

    Like

    Reply

Leave a Reply